Thursday, July 20, 2006

Fantasy football projection comparison, 2005: Running Backs

Running Backs:
Different scoring system
Different scoring systemDifferent scoring systemDifferent scoring systemDifferent scoring system
RankActual (Yahoo default)ESPN (Consensus of users)Sportsline (expert)Yahoo (Projections*)NFL Record & Fact Book (Projections)KUBIAK (Projections)
1Shaun AlexanderLaDainian TomlinsonLaDainian TomlinsonLaDainian TomlinsonLaDainian TomlinsonLaDainian Tomlinson
2LaDainian TomlinsonShaun AlexanderShaun AlexanderShaun AlexanderPriest HolmesDomanick Davis
3Larry JohnsonPriest HolmesPriest HolmesPriest HolmesEdgerrin JamesEdgerrin James
4Tiki BarberEdgerrin JamesEdgerrin JamesEdgerrin JamesShaun AlexanderShaun Alexander
5Edgerrin JamesDeuce McAllisterDomanick DavisWillis McGaheeJamal LewisTiki Barber
6Clinton PortisWillis McGaheeWillis McGaheeCorey DillonCorey DillonJulius Jones
7Rudi JohnsonJamal LewisJamal LewisJamal LewisDomanick DavisClinton Portis
8LaMont JordanKevin JonesCorey DillonDeuce McAllisterClinton PortisKevin Jones
9Mike AndersonClinton PortisDeuce McAllisterDomanick DavisJulius JonesWillis McGahee
10Corey DillonAhman GreenAhman GreenTiki BarberRudi JohnsonBrian Westbrook
11Thomas JonesDomanick DavisClinton PortisAhman GreenAhman GreenPriest Holmes
12Stephen JacksonCorey DillonJulius JonesClinton PortisDeuce McAllisterRudi Johnson
13Stephen Davis
Tiki BarberKevin JonesJulius JonesWillis McGaheeDeuce McAllister
14Brian WestbrookRudi JohnsonRudi JohnsonRudi JohnsonTiki BarberRonnie Brown
15Warrick DunnJulius JonesTiki BarberKevin JonesChris BrownSteven Jackson
16Willie ParkerLaMont JordanLaMont JordanCurtis MartinBrian WestbrookAhman Green
17Domanick DavisBrian WestbrookCurtis MartinSteven JacksonSteven JacksonCurtis Martin
18Tatum BellCurtis MartinBrian WestbrookBrian WestbrookKevin JonesCorey Dillon
19Willis McGaheeFred TaylorSteven JacksonTatum BellCurtis MartinLaMont Jordan
20Carnell WilliamsSteven JacksonMike AndersonLaMont JordanTatum BellCarnell Williams
21Chris BrownTatum BellCarnell WilliamsChris BrownLaMont JordanMichael Bennett
22Reuben DroughnsThomas JonesJ.J. ArringtonWillie ParkerThomas JonesKevan Barlow
23Julius JonesChris BrownFred TaylorDeShaun FosterKevan BarlowJ.J. Arrington
24Ricky Williams
Travis HenryWarrick DunnCarnell WilliamsDeShaun FosterJamal Lewis
25Jerome BettisWarrick DunnLarry JohnsonDuce StaleyFred TaylorFred Taylor
26Priest HolmesKevan BarlowMichael BennettMike AndersonMichael PittmanThomas Jones
27Samkon GadoDuce StaleyChris BrownWarrick DunnDuce StaleyWarrick Dunn
28DeShaun FosterOnterrio SmithRonnie BrownMichael BennettWarrick DunnTatum Bell
29Ronnie BrownDeShaun FosterThomas JonesFred TaylorLarry JohnsonCedric Benson
30Mewelde MooreReuben DroughnsTravis HenryJ.J. ArringtonOnterrio SmithReuben Droughns
31Curtis MartinCarnell WilliamsDeShaun FosterRonnie BrownMichael BennettMewelde Moore
32T.J. DuckettT.J. DuckettKevan BarlowStephen DavisT.J. DuckettFrank Gore
33Kevin JonesJ.J. ArringtonCedric BensonKevan BarlowDerrick BlaylockDeShaun Foster
34Jamal LewisLee SuggsTatum BellCedric BensonTravis HenryT.J. Duckett
35Marion BarberRonnie BrownStephen DavisJerome BettisReuben DroughnsTravis Henry
36Fred TaylorJerome BettisLee SuggsRicky WilliamsJerome BettisDerrick Blaylock
37Mike AlstottCedric BensonRicky WilliamsLarry JohnsonMarcel ShippNick Goings
38Mike SellersMichael BennettJerome BettisThomas JonesStephen DavisRyan Moats
39Kevan BarlowLarry JohnsonReuben DroughnsReuben DroughnsLee SuggsChris Brown
40Greg JonesMichael PittmanT.J. DuckettMarshall FaulkMarshall FaulkMichael Pittman
41Michael BennettDerrick BlaylockMarshall FaulkTravis HenryDominic RhodesMike Anderson
42Frank GoreMarshall FaulkWillie ParkerT.J. DuckettCorrell BuckhalterJerome Bettis
43Kyle JohnsonRicky WilliamsMewelde MooreMichael PittmanChester TaylorVerron Haynes
44Brandon JacobsKevin FaulkMichael PittmanLee SuggsLadell BettsDuce Staley
45Antowain SmithCorrell BuckhalterDuce StaleyChris CooleyTroy HambrickLarry Johnson
46Michael PittmanNick GoingsNajeh Davenport
Mewelde MooreShawn Bryson
47Deuce McAllisterLadell BettsMarcel Shipp
Sammy MorrisRicky Williams
48Artose PinnerMarcel ShippDerrick Blaylock
Nick GoingsLaBrandon Toefield
49Patrick PassNajeh DavenportDominic Rhodes
x - J.J. ArringtonKevin Faulk
50Maurice HicksMike AndersonChester Taylor
x - Ronnie BrownMarshall Faulk
51Chris PerryStephen DavisFrank Gore
x - Carnell WilliamsEric Shelton
52LaBrandon ToefieldChester TaylorLaBrandon Toefield
x - Cedric AbensonChester Taylor
53Tony FisherMewelde MooreBrandon Jacobs
Greg JonesMoe Williams
54Michael TurnerLamar GordonWilliam Green
Mauric HicksAnthony Thomas
55Adrian PetersonVerron HaynesAnthony Thomas
Najeh DavenportDominic Rhodes
56Chester TaylorAntowain SmithRyan Moats
x - Eric SheltonMarcel Shipp
57Ryan MoatsLaBrandon ToefieldMoe Williams
Verron HaynesBrandon Jacobs
58Ladell BettsAmos ZereoueSammy Morris
William HendersonCiatrick Fason
59

Kevin Faulk
Jonathan WellsJerald Sowell
60

Aaron Stecker
Tony FisherMike Alstott
61



Shawn BrysonWilliam Green
62



Quentin GriffinTony Fisher
63



Kevin FaulkAaron Stecker
64



Mike AlstottNajeh Davenport
65



Eddie GeorgeGreg Jones
66



Anthony ThomasJ.R. Redmond
67



Antowain SmithLee Suggs
68



Mike CloudMaurice Hicks
69



Jesse ChatmanZack Crockett
70



Zack CrockettAntowain Smith
71



Chris PerryQuentin Griffin
72



LaBrandon ToefieldVernand Morency
73



Lamar GordonShaud Williams
74



Tyrone WheatleySammy Morris
75



Maurice MorrisDamien Nash
76



Arlen HarrisChris Perry
77



Obafemi AyanbadejoStephen Davis
78



Justin GriffithJustin Fargas
79



Brad HooverMaurice Morris
80



Moe WilliamsArtose Pinner
81



Cory SchlesingerLamar Gordon
82



Charlie GarnerMaurice Clarett
83



x - Frank GoreAlvin Pearman
84



x - Cedric HoustonLadell Betts
85



x - Marion BarberMichael Turner
86



x - Anthony DavisJonathan Wells
87



Patrick PassMike Cloud
88



x - Maurice ClarettTony Hollings
89



Chris Fuamatu-Ma'afala
90



Dan Kreider
91



Mack Strong
92



J.R. Redmond
93



Amos Zereoue
94



Dorsey Levens
95



Justin Fargas
96



William Green
97



Fred Beasley
98



Jeremi Johnson
99



Ron Dayne
100



Tony Richardson

Comments on "Fantasy football projection comparison, 2005: Running Backs"

 

Anonymous Miles Libbey said ... (3:42 AM, July 27, 2006) : 

Any chance you could post the actual numbers? I'd like to
a)do a variance of the projected points minus the actual [Julius Jones in Kubiak versus actual] and
b)do a sum of the differences of the points gained at that rank [JJ picked at 6 versus the ideal of Portis at 6]. With only the ranks, you don't really know how bad the mistake was. For instance, KUBIAK put Julius Jones at 6, whereas he ended up at 22. If this represented 10 points, who cares? If it represents 100 points, its a big miss. Similarly, if JJ only got 100 points, and Portis got 200 points, KUBIAK lost 100 points by choosing him there.

 

Anonymous Miles Libbey said ... (10:39 AM, July 28, 2006) : 

thanks for the update. formatting-wise, the non RB posts over run with the right hand table of contents. I don't see an obvious way to fix this-- the table needs to be a lot smaller to fit.
If you have the raw data of the different site's projections (in yards), I'd love a copy -- mlibbeymail-blogs at yahoo (that's dot com). Thanks!

 

post a comment