Fantasy football projection comparison, 2005: Quarterbacks

Quarterbacks: Different Scoring System Different Scoring System Different Scoring System Different Scoring System Different Scoring System Rank Actual (Yahoo default) ESPN (Consensus of users) Sportsline (expert) Yahoo (Projections*) NFL Record & Fact Book (Projections) KUBIAK (Projections) 1 Carson Palmer Peyton Manning Peyton Manning Peyton Manning Peyton Manning Peyton Manning 2 Peyton Manning Daunte Culpepper Daunte Culpepper Daunte Culpepper Daunte Culpepper Daunte Culpepper 3 Tom Brady Donovan McNabb Donovan McNabb Donovan McNabb Donovan McNabb Donovan McNabb 4 Matt Hasselbeck Trent Green Brett Favre Trent Green Trent Green Matt Hasselbeck 5 Eli Manning Marc Bulger Trent Green Brett Favre Kerry Collins Kerry Collins 6 Drew Brees Brett Favre Kerry Collins Tom Brady Michael Vick Marc Bulger 7 Jake Delhomme Michael Vick Tom Brady Marc Bulger Marc Bulger Byron Leftwich 8 Drew Bledsoe Kerry Collins Marc Bulger Michael Vick Matt Hasselbeck Jake Plummer 9 Jake Plummer Tom Brady Michael Vick Drew Brees Aaron Brooks Tom Brady 10 Mark Brunell Aaron Brooks Matt Hasselbeck Matt Hasselbeck Carson Palmer Aaron Brooks 11 Kerry Collins Matt Hasselbeck Jake Plummer Kerry Collins Brett Favre David Carr 12 Michael Vick Drew Brees Jake Delhomme Carson Palmer Tom Brady Chad Pennington 13 Trent Green Jake Plummer Carson Palmer Aaron Brooks Jake Plummer Carson Palmer 14 Ben Roethlisberger Jake Delhomme Drew Brees Jake Delhomme David Carr Ben Roethlisberger 15 Steve McNair Carson Palmer Steve McNair Ben Roethlisberger Jake Delhomme Brett Favre 16 Gus Frerotte David Carr Aaron Brooks Jake Plummer Chad Pennington Trent Green 17 Donovan McNabb Byron Leftwich Chad Pennington Drew Bledsoe Steve McNair Brian Griese 18 Byron Leftwich Ben Roethlisberger Byron Leftwich Chad Pennington Byron Leftwich Drew Brees 19 Brett Favre Chad Pennington David Carr Eli Manning Brian Griese Jake Delhomme 20 Aaron Brooks Brian Griese Brian Griese Steve McNair Joey Harrington Michael Vick 21 David Carr Steve McNair Joey Harrington Byron Leftwich Drew Brees Eli Manning 22 Mark Bulger Joey Harrington Eli Manning Joey Harrington Patrick Ramsey J.P. Losman 23 Kurt Warner Kyle Boller Kurt Warner David Carr Eli Manning Kyle Boller 24 Brad Johnson Drew Bledsoe Ben Roethlisberger Kurt Warner Ben Roethlisberger Drew Bledsoe 25 Kyle Boller Rex Grossman Drew Bledsoe Patrick Ramsey Kurt Warner Steve McNair 26 Joey Harrington Eli Manning Kyle Boller Brian Griese Drew Bledsoe Kurt Warner 27 Chris Simms Kurt Warner Patrick Ramsey Rex Grossman Joey Harrington 28 Trent Dilfer J.P. Losman J.P. Losman Trent Dilfer Trent Dilfer 29 Kelly Holcomb Trent Dilfer J.P. Losman Jeff Garcia 30 David Garrard Tim Rattay Kyle Boller Alex Smith 31 Josh McCown Gus Frerotte Tim Rattay Tim Rattay 32 Brooks Bollinger Kyle Orton Gus Frerotte Patrick Ramsey 33 Billy Volek Billy Volek A.J. Feeley 34 Brad Johnson Jeff Garcia Gus Frerotte 35 Kelly Holcomb Kelly Holcomb Chad Hutchinson 36 Alex Smith A.J. Felley Kyle Orton 37 Philip Rivers Jay Fiedler Billy Volek 38 Jon Kitna Brad Johnson Kelly Holcomb 39 Jay Fielder Jim Sorgi Josh McCown 40 Tommy Maddox Mike McMahon Drew Henson 41 x - Alex Smith Matt Schaub 42 Matt Schaub Philip Rivers 43 Josh McCown Jon Kitna 44 Chad Hutchinson David Garrard 45 Drew Henson Jay Fiedler 46 David Garrard Tommy Maddox 47 Philip Rivers 48 Jon Kitna 49 Luke McCown 50 Tommy Maddox 51 x - Aaron Rodgers 52 Kordell Stewrt 53 x - Jason Campbell 54 Jeff Blake 55 Mark Brunell 56 Tony Banks 57 Jamie Martin 58 Todd Collins 59 Chris Simms 60 Doug Flutie