Fantasy football projection comparison, 2006: Quarterbacks, Table 1

PreRank: the default rank of the player in the given projection. SimPts: the number of points the QB is projected to score under a simplified Yahoo system, crediting 6 points per passing or rushing touchdown, -2 points per interception, 1 point for every 50 passing yards, and 1 point for every 20 rushing yards. SimRank: the rank of the player in the given projection under the simplified Yahoo scoring system. TABLE 1: 2006 QB CBS FOX Yahoo Player PreRank SimPts SimRank PreRank SimPts SimRank PreRank SimPts SimRank Derek Anderson 84 0 69 - - - 80 0 74 Tom Arth 79 0 69 - - - 87 0 74 Charlie Batch 52 11 51 55 8 46 59 0.8 45 Drew Bledsoe 7 194 9 13 186 8 12 213 8 Kyle Boller 37 26 37 44 16 42 29 0.8 45 Brooks Bollinger 60 5 62 - - - 52 0 74 Todd Bouman - - - - - - 113 0.2 70 Shane Boyd 75 0 69 - - - - - - Tom Brady 2 232 2 2 214 3 3 196.8 9 Casey Bramlet 71 0 69 - - - 73 0 74 Drew Brees 10 193 10 15 168 13 16 157 24 Aaron Brooks 19 169 17 20 127 26 20 182 14 Travis Brown - - - - - - 75 0 74 Mark Brunell 21 165 20 21 130 25 19 220.2 4 Marc Bulger 9 201 6 10 156 15 7 182.2 13 Jason Campbell 63 6 57 50 38 37 68 1 36 David Carr 23 144 23 22 149 17 24 133.8 30 Matt Cassel 58 6 57 49 0 48 83 0.6 56 Timmy Chang 73 0 69 - - - - - - Kellen Clemens 82 0 69 - - - 69 0.2 70 Kerry Collins - - - - - - 39 0 74 Todd Collins 67 4 66 - - - 79 0.6 60 Daunte Culpepper 13 190 12 7 167 14 8 218.4 5 Jay Cutler - - - - - - 90 1 36 Rohan Davey - - - - - - 111 0 74 Jake Delhomme 15 189 14 9 206 4 10 188.8 10 Koy Detmer - - - - - - 114 0 74 Trent Dilfer 40 18 46 47 22 39 50 0.4 64 Ken Dorsey 47 15 47 - - - 108 1 36 Brett Favre 12 186 15 17 138 22 15 167.6 21 A.J. Feeley - - - 45 0 48 54 1.6 33 Jay Fiedler - - - - - - 55 0.6 56 Ryan Fitzpatrick - - - - - - 41 0 74 Gus Frerotte 42 20 43 40 44 36 43 1 36 Charlie Frye 30 127 29 30 142 21 28 145.6 26 Jeff Garcia 45 22 41 48 8 46 51 0.8 45 David Garrard 41 23 39 27 17 41 40 1 36 Bruce Gradkowski - - - - - - 100 0 74 Quinn Gray 54 6 57 - - - 72 0 74 Trent Green 11 190 12 8 188 6 9 184.4 12 David Greene - - - - - - 102 0 74 Brian Griese 36 24 38 38 20 40 35 0.8 45 Rex Grossman 28 128 28 31 103 31 37 136.8 28 Gibran Hamdan - - - - - - 64 0 74 Joey Harrington 34 28 36 37 0 48 45 0.8 45 Josh Harris - - - - - - 63 0 74 Matt Hasselbeck 4 209 3 3 219 2 5 213.8 7 Tim Hasselbeck 57 6 57 - - - 97 1 36 Drew Henson - - - - - - 76 0 74 Shaun Hill - - - - - - 99 0.6 60 Kelly Holcomb 29 117 30 36 110 29 42 163.2 23 Damon Huard 74 0 69 - - - 56 0.4 64 Brad Johnson 24 144 23 23 174 11 21 144 27 Doug Johnson 59 6 57 - - - 101 0 74 Rob Johnson - - - 56 0 48 57 1 36 James Kilian - - - - - - 82 0 74 Shaun King - - - - - - 78 0 74 Kliff Kingsbury - - - - - - 65 0 74 Jon Kitna 22 148 22 28 106 30 27 169 20 Craig Krenzel - - - - - - 109 0 74 Stefan LeFors 76 0 69 - - - 95 0 74 Byron Leftwich 17 175 16 18 146 19 18 171.6 17 Matt Leinart 46 19 44 25 70 33 33 0.8 45 Cleo Lemon 62 5 62 - - - 104 0.6 60 Jared Lorenzen - - - - - - 84 0 74 J.P. Losman 38 30 35 34 15 43 47 0.4 64 Eli Manning 5 204 5 5 194 5 4 170.6 18 Peyton Manning 1 262 1 1 237 1 1 283.2 1 Jamie Martin 50 12 49 - - - 53 0.8 45 Matt Mauck - - - - - - 98 0 74 Josh McCown 35 32 34 42 46 35 26 1.4 35 Luke McCown 68 4 66 - - - 106 0.4 64 Mike McMahon 48 13 48 - - - 49 0.8 45 Donovan McNabb 6 198 7 6 188 6 6 176.6 16 Steve McNair 20 160 21 16 146 19 23 156.6 25 Adrian McPherson - - - - - - 60 0 74 Craig Nall 56 7 55 - - - 38 0 74 John Navarre 66 5 62 - - - 96 0.2 70 Dan Orlovsky - - - - - - 81 0 74 Kyle Orton 61 7 55 32 0 48 110 0 74 J.T. O'Sullivan - - - - - - 103 0 74 Jeff Otis 83 0 69 - - - - - - Carson Palmer 3 208 4 4 183 9 2 226 3 Jesse Palmer - - - - - - 85 0 74 Preston Parsons 70 0 69 - - - 67 0 74 Chad Pennington 32 117 30 26 111 28 22 133 31 Cody Pickett - - - - - - 70 0 74 Jake Plummer 18 166 19 11 177 10 14 231.6 2 Casey Printers 72 0 69 - - - - - - Dave Ragone - - - - - - 94 0 74 Patrick Ramsey 39 21 42 51 29 38 34 0 74 Bryan Randall - - - - - - 88 0 74 Marcus Randall 69 0 69 - - - - - - Tim Rattay - - - 43 0 48 44 0.4 64 Philip Rivers 26 135 26 33 137 23 25 164.6 22 Aaron Rodgers - - - - - - 71 0.6 56 Ben Roethlisberger 16 191 11 14 170 12 13 216 6 Tony Romo - - - - - - 77 1 36 Sage Rosenfels 49 12 49 53 0 48 46 1.11E-16 73 Rod Rutherford 78 0 69 - - - - - - Matt Schaub 43 23 39 39 9 45 105 0.4 64 Chris Simms 25 136 25 24 137 23 30 134.8 29 Alex Smith 31 107 32 35 101 32 36 85 32 Jeff Smoker - - - - - - 92 0 74 Jim Sorgi 55 9 53 - - - 107 1.6 33 Bryson Spinner 77 0 69 - - - - - - Brian St. Pierre 81 0 69 - - - 93 0 74 B.J. Symons - - - - - - 91 0 74 Marques Tuiasosopo - - - - - - 86 0.6 56 Bradlee Van Pelt 53 11 51 - - - 58 0.6 60 Marcus Vick 51 2 68 - - - 74 0 74 Michael Vick 14 169 17 12 155 16 17 177 15 Billy Volek 27 133 27 29 120 27 31 170 19 Seneca Wallace 65 9 53 - - - 112 0.8 45 Andrew Walter 64 5 62 - - - 66 0 74 Kurt Warner 8 196 8 19 148 18 11 186 11 Chris Weinke - - - - - - 62 1 36 Charlie Whitehurst - - - - - - 61 0 74 Tory Woodbury 80 0 69 - - - 89 0 74 Anthony Wright 44 19 44 54 14 44 48 0.8 45 Vince Young 33 63 33 41 53 34 32 0.8 45